Blog

O2’s legal challenge to UK auction is not a one-off

The UK's regulator has had a frustrating couple of months in its efforts to assign the 700 MHz and 3.6 - 3.8 GHz bands. For a start, the Coronavirus pandemic has made it harder to get anything done, especially something as sensitive as a spectrum auction. In response to the pandemic, mobile operator Vodafone further undermined Ofcom's plans by calling for the auction's cancellation in favour of a beauty contest.…
The UK's regulator has had a frustrating couple of months in its efforts to assign the 700 MHz and 3.6 - 3.8 GHz bands. For a start, the Coronavirus pandemic has made it harder to get anything done, especially something as sensitive as a spectrum auction. In response to the pandemic, mobile operator Vodafone further undermined Ofcom's plans by calling for the auction's cancellation in favour of a beauty contest. Its rationale was that operators could more quickly put the spectrum to use if it was assigned directly, rather than auctioned. Its competitor, O2, has now gone further and has told Ofcom it may sue the regulator over block sizes. These nuisances might be a surprise to some spectrum managers seeing as one of the main advantages of spectrum auctions over other assignment methods is its supposed resistance to legal challenge. The criteria used for beauty contests, for example, can be subjective and open to interpretation, whereas a spectrum auction creates clear winners and losers. But in an analysis of spectrum auctions, we find the history of spectrum auctions littered with lawsuits related to state aid, spectrum caps, and reserve prices, among other things. The research note, Spectrum auctions are not immune to legal challengesis available to Spectrum Research Service subscribers.

Blog

Img Alt

Newsletter

Discover why hundreds of regulators and technology companies use our services

SUBSCRIBE
Comments
Telefónica criticises EU Orange/MásMóvil merger decision
The Spanish government approved the..." by Mirva Villa
Mar 13, 2024
Exclusive: Director of the ITU Radiocommunication Bureau on WRC-23 
Noted and amended. Many thanks Nikolai." by Laura Sear
Mar 13, 2024
Exclusive: Director of the ITU Radiocommunication Bureau on WRC-23 
Not everyone knows that NOW4WRC23..." by Nikolai Shienok
Mar 13, 2024
Regulators should prioritise social welfare, not infrastructure targets
Richard, thanks for amending the text...." by Nikolai Shienok
Feb 16, 2024
Regulators should prioritise social welfare, not infrastructure targets
Thanks for spotting this Nikolai. We've..." by Richard Haas
Feb 16, 2024