Blog

Will the incentive auction suffer a public perception problem?

It's not the biggest or most popular broadcasters which are being offered the largest incentives....
| PolicyTracker

The largest amounts are not being offered to the stations which have the most viewers, generate the most profit or produce the best programmes.

My colleague David Yip has pointed out a little-noticed aspect of the forthcoming US incentive auction. As we know, broadcasters are being offered cash incentives to give up their 600 MHz spectrum, but the differences in the amounts have been given little attention. 

Proportionately, the largest sums are not being offered to the stations which have the most viewers, generate the most profit or produce the best programmes. Who gets the most is something of a “zip code lottery.” 

Most of the biggest beneficiaries are broadcasters just outside dense urban areas. In simple terms the TV station’s high power signals may be blocking the use of several potential 600 MHz mobile licences in the city, so the FCC is prepared to offer them more to vacate the spectrum. 

And by “more”, we mean up to $224MHz/pop: over 100 times more than the lowest offer to broadcasters or 32 times the highest price ever paid for a 700 MHz licence ($7.5 MHz/pop).

Is this unjust enrichment for these broadcasters? Why should the accident of their location bequeath them such a windfall? Is it fair that stations with more viewers can receive much less?

With spectrum auctions, economic theory may tell us one thing but public opinion may take the opposite view. New Zealand was following the nobel prize winner William Vickery in 1990 when it sold a spectrum licence in a second price auction but the public was horrified when a company which offered NZ$100,000 had to pay only NZ$6.

Will the incentive auction suffer the same fate? We will find out this year when the reverse auction gives the range of prices broadcasters will accept, and the forward action tells us how much mobile operators are prepared to pay.

The US has offered other countries the use of its software to clear their own broadcast spectrum. If other nations accept, will they also offer such a wide range of incentives? The reaction of the US public will be a key factor in making this decision.

Img Alt

Newsletter

Discover why hundreds of regulators and technology companies use our services

SUBSCRIBE
Comments
US to force automakers to support AM radio
Hi Richard. I agree. I was suprised how..." by Richard Haas
Oct 23, 2024
US to force automakers to support AM radio
The reason AM radios are unpopular for..." by Richard Womersley
Oct 22, 2024
Committee of MPs warns UK unlikely to meet 4G or 5G mobile coverage targets
Ofcom has provided an update today..." by Mirva Villa
Sep 12, 2024
Dominican Republic auction declared invalid
Claro launched 5G in the Dominican..." by Richard Womersley
Aug 29, 2024
Georgia to hold second 5G auction with relaxed obligations
PolicyTracker approached the regulator..." by Mirva Villa
Aug 23, 2024